While those vintage-style boots might look the part, your primary focus should be on arch support and ankle stability. Square dancing involves a lot of pivoting, twisting, and quick weight changes. Look for shoes with a well-defined, supportive arch and a heel counter that cups your heel firmly without biting.

Pro Tip: Press on the sides of the heel in the shoe. If it collapses easily, it won't provide enough support during vigorous dances.

This is non-negotiable. You need a sole that provides just the right amount of slide and grip. Leather or suede soles are the gold standard for square dance shoes. They allow you to pivot smoothly without sticking to the floor or sliding uncontrollably. Avoid rubber soles found on everyday sneakers—they grip too much and can lead to knee and ankle injuries from twisted pivots.

An evening of do-si-do-ing will get your feet moving and sweating. Shoes made from breathable materials like high-quality leather, canvas, or modern performance mesh will allow air to circulate, keeping your feet cooler and more comfortable. This also helps prevent blisters and reduces moisture that can break down the shoe's interior faster.

Your dance shoes should fit like a glove—snug but not tight. There should be no heel slippage, and your toes should have just enough room to wiggle slightly without sliding forward when you pivot. Remember, your feet may swell slightly after hours of dancing, so consider trying on shoes later in the day when your feet are at their largest.

Pro Tip: Always try shoes on with the same type of socks or hosiery you plan to wear while dancing.

Durability is key. Examine how the shoe is put together. Look for reinforced stitching, especially in high-stress areas like the toe (for scuffing) and the ball of the foot (for pivoting). A well-constructed shoe with a sturdy sole that can be replaced by a cobbler is a more sustainable and economical choice in the long run than a cheaply made pair you'll need to replace every season.